Table of Contents
Introduction
Glasgow Rangers is a Scottish professional football club based in Glasgow, Scotland. The club has a long and storied history, having been founded in 1872. However, there has been much debate and controversy over whether or not the current Glasgow Rangers is the same club that was founded in 1872. This question has been the subject of much discussion among football fans and historians alike.
History of Glasgow Rangers Football Club
Glasgow Rangers Football Club is one of the oldest and most successful football clubs in Scotland. Founded in 1872, the club has a rich history and a loyal fan base. However, in recent years, there has been a debate about whether the current Glasgow Rangers Football Club is the same club that was founded in 1872.
The debate started in 2012 when the club went into administration and was subsequently liquidated. The club’s assets were then purchased by a new company, which formed a new club called Rangers Football Club. This led to a dispute about whether the new club was the same as the old club.
The argument against the new club being the same as the old club is based on the fact that the old club was liquidated and ceased to exist. The new club, therefore, cannot claim to be the same club as the old one. This argument is supported by the fact that the new club had to apply for membership to the Scottish Football Association (SFA) and was granted membership as a new club.
However, the argument in favor of the new club being the same as the old club is based on the fact that the new club purchased the assets of the old club, including the history, trophies, and records. The new club also plays at the same stadium, Ibrox, and has the same colors and badge as the old club. This argument is supported by the fact that the SFA recognizes the new club as a continuation of the old club.
To understand the debate, it is important to look at the history of Glasgow Rangers Football Club. The club was founded in 1872 by four men who were members of the Protestant community in Glasgow. The club’s early years were marked by success, and it quickly became one of the most successful clubs in Scotland.
In the 1890s, the club moved to its current home, Ibrox Stadium, and continued to dominate Scottish football. The club won its first Scottish League title in 1891 and went on to win many more titles in the following years. The club also had success in European competitions, winning the European Cup Winners’ Cup in 1972.
However, the club’s success was not without controversy. The club’s fans were known for their sectarianism, and there were many incidents of violence and bigotry. The club’s rivalry with Celtic, another Glasgow-based club, was particularly intense and often led to violence.
In 2012, the club went into administration due to financial difficulties. The club was subsequently liquidated, and its assets were purchased by a new company, which formed a new club called Rangers Football Club. The new club was granted membership to the SFA and started playing in the Scottish Third Division.
Since then, the new club has worked its way back up the Scottish football pyramid and is currently playing in the Scottish Premiership. The club has also won several trophies, including the Scottish Championship, Scottish Cup, and Scottish League Cup.
In conclusion, the debate about whether Glasgow Rangers Football Club is the same club as the one founded in 1872 is a complex one. While the new club purchased the assets of the old club and has the same history, trophies, and records, it was also formed as a new club and had to apply for membership to the SFA. Ultimately, the answer to the question of whether Glasgow Rangers Football Club is the same club depends on one’s perspective. However, what is clear is that the club has a rich history and a loyal fan base, and it will continue to be a major force in Scottish football for years to come.
Legal Dispute: The Battle Over Rangers’ Identity
The Glasgow Rangers Football Club is one of the most successful football clubs in Scotland, with a rich history dating back to 1872. However, in recent years, the club has been embroiled in a legal dispute over its identity. The question at the heart of the dispute is whether the current Glasgow Rangers Football Club is the same club that was founded in 1872, or whether it is a new club that was formed in 2012.
The dispute began in 2012 when the Glasgow Rangers Football Club went into administration and was subsequently liquidated. The club’s assets were then purchased by a new company called Sevco Scotland Ltd, which renamed the club as The Rangers Football Club Ltd. The new club was then granted membership to the Scottish Football Association (SFA) and began playing in the Scottish Third Division.
However, many fans and rival clubs argued that the new club was not the same as the old Glasgow Rangers Football Club. They claimed that the new club was a completely different entity, with no right to claim the history and traditions of the old club. They argued that the old club had been liquidated and ceased to exist, and that the new club was simply a continuation of the old club’s legacy.
The dispute was further complicated by the fact that the old club’s history and records were transferred to a new company called Rangers Football Club Ltd (RFC 2012), which was owned by the same people who owned Sevco Scotland Ltd. This led to accusations that the new club was attempting to rewrite history and claim credit for the achievements of the old club.
The legal dispute over the identity of the Glasgow Rangers Football Club has been ongoing for several years. In 2013, the SFA appointed an independent commission to investigate the matter. The commission concluded that the new club was a continuation of the old club’s history and traditions, and that it was entitled to claim the honours and achievements of the old club.
However, this decision was not accepted by everyone. Many fans and rival clubs continued to argue that the new club was not the same as the old club, and that it had no right to claim the history and traditions of the old club. The dispute has continued to simmer, with occasional flare-ups of controversy and debate.
In 2018, the dispute took a new turn when a group of Rangers fans launched a legal challenge against the SFA, arguing that the new club was not the same as the old club. The case was heard by the Scottish Court of Session, which ruled in favour of the SFA and upheld the previous decision that the new club was a continuation of the old club’s history and traditions.
Despite this ruling, the dispute over the identity of the Glasgow Rangers Football Club is unlikely to go away anytime soon. Many fans and rival clubs remain deeply divided on the issue, and the controversy is likely to continue to generate heated debate and discussion for years to come.
In conclusion, the legal dispute over the identity of the Glasgow Rangers Football Club is a complex and contentious issue that has divided fans and rival clubs for many years. While the SFA and the Scottish Court of Session have ruled that the new club is a continuation of the old club’s history and traditions, many fans and rival clubs continue to argue that the new club is not the same as the old club. The dispute is likely to continue to generate controversy and debate for many years to come, and it remains to be seen whether a definitive resolution will ever be reached.
Impact of Rangers’ Liquidation on the Club’s Identity
The liquidation of Glasgow Rangers in 2012 was a significant event in Scottish football history. The club, which had been a dominant force in Scottish football for over a century, was forced to start again from the bottom of the Scottish football pyramid. However, the question that has been asked by many football fans is whether the new Rangers are the same club as the old Rangers.
The answer to this question is not straightforward. On the one hand, the new Rangers were formed by a consortium led by Charles Green, who purchased the assets of the old Rangers from the liquidators. This means that the new Rangers have the same name, badge, and history as the old Rangers. However, on the other hand, the new Rangers were not granted membership of the Scottish Football Association (SFA) immediately, and had to apply for membership of the Scottish Professional Football League (SPFL) as a new club.
The SFA’s decision not to grant the new Rangers immediate membership was based on the fact that the old Rangers had been liquidated, and therefore no longer existed. The SFA argued that the new Rangers were a new club, and therefore had to apply for membership like any other new club. This decision was controversial, and many Rangers fans felt that their club’s identity had been taken away from them.
Despite this controversy, the new Rangers were eventually granted membership of the SPFL, and have since been playing in the Scottish Premiership. However, the question of whether they are the same club as the old Rangers continues to be debated.
One argument in favour of the new Rangers being the same club as the old Rangers is that they have the same name, badge, and history. The new Rangers have continued to play at Ibrox Stadium, which has been the home of Rangers since 1899. They have also continued to wear the famous blue shirt with a white diagonal stripe, which has been associated with Rangers since the early 20th century. In addition, the new Rangers have continued to celebrate the club’s history, including their many league titles and European successes.
Another argument in favour of the new Rangers being the same club as the old Rangers is that they have the same fanbase. Rangers fans have continued to support the club through thick and thin, and have remained loyal to the club despite the challenges of the last decade. The new Rangers have also continued to attract new fans, particularly younger fans who have grown up with the club as a dominant force in Scottish football.
However, there are also arguments against the new Rangers being the same club as the old Rangers. One argument is that the new Rangers are a different legal entity from the old Rangers. The old Rangers were a company that was liquidated, while the new Rangers are a new company that was formed by a consortium led by Charles Green. This means that the new Rangers are not the same legal entity as the old Rangers, and therefore cannot be considered the same club.
Another argument against the new Rangers being the same club as the old Rangers is that they have not won any major trophies since their formation. The old Rangers were a dominant force in Scottish football, winning 54 league titles, 33 Scottish Cups, and 27 League Cups. The new Rangers have yet to win a major trophy, and have only won promotion to the Scottish Premiership once since their formation.
In conclusion, the question of whether the new Rangers are the same club as the old Rangers is a complex one. While the new Rangers have the same name, badge, and history as the old Rangers, they are also a different legal entity and have not won any major trophies since their formation. Ultimately, the answer to this question may depend on individual interpretation, and may never be fully resolved. However, what is clear is that Rangers remains a hugely important club in Scottish football, and will continue to be so for many years to come.
Fan Perspectives: Is Rangers Still the Same Club?
The question of whether Glasgow Rangers is still the same club has been a topic of debate among football fans for years. The club has undergone significant changes in recent years, including financial difficulties, relegation to the fourth tier of Scottish football, and a change in ownership. These changes have led some fans to question whether the club is still the same entity that they have supported for decades.
One of the main arguments against Rangers being the same club is the fact that the club was liquidated in 2012. This means that the old company that owned the club was dissolved, and a new company was formed to take its place. Some fans argue that this means that the club is no longer the same entity, as it is now owned by a different company.
However, many fans argue that the club is still the same, despite the change in ownership. They point to the fact that the new company that owns the club was formed specifically to continue the legacy of the old club. The new company purchased the assets of the old club, including the stadium, training ground, and intellectual property, and has continued to play under the same name and colours.
Another argument in favour of Rangers being the same club is the fact that the club has a long and storied history. The club was founded in 1872 and has won numerous domestic and international titles over the years. Many fans argue that this history and tradition are what make Rangers the same club, regardless of any changes in ownership or financial difficulties.
However, some fans argue that the club’s recent financial difficulties and relegation to the fourth tier of Scottish football have tarnished its reputation and legacy. They argue that the club’s success in the past is no longer relevant, and that the current state of the club is what matters.
Despite these differing opinions, one thing is clear: Rangers remains a hugely popular and important club in Scottish football. The club has a large and passionate fanbase, and its matches are watched by millions of people around the world. Whether or not the club is still the same entity that it was in the past, it is clear that it will continue to be a major force in Scottish football for years to come.
In conclusion, the question of whether Glasgow Rangers is still the same club is a complex and contentious one. While some fans argue that the club’s recent financial difficulties and change in ownership mean that it is no longer the same entity, others point to the club’s long and storied history as evidence that it remains the same. Ultimately, the answer to this question may depend on one’s personal perspective and attachment to the club. However, one thing is certain: Rangers will continue to be a major force in Scottish football, regardless of any changes in ownership or financial difficulties.
Comparing Rangers’ Achievements Before and After Liquidation
The question of whether Glasgow Rangers are the same club before and after liquidation has been a topic of debate among football fans for years. While some argue that the club is still the same, others believe that the new Rangers are a completely different entity. One way to compare the two is by looking at their achievements before and after liquidation.
Before liquidation, Rangers were one of the most successful clubs in Scottish football history. They won 54 league titles, 33 Scottish Cups, and 27 League Cups. They also reached the final of the European Cup Winners’ Cup twice, winning it once in 1972. Their success on the pitch was matched by their financial stability off it, with the club being debt-free for many years.
However, in 2012, Rangers went into administration due to financial mismanagement. The club was then liquidated and a new company, Rangers Football Club Ltd, was formed to take its place. The new Rangers were forced to start again in the fourth tier of Scottish football, with all their previous achievements wiped from the record books.
Since then, the new Rangers have been working hard to rebuild the club and regain their place at the top of Scottish football. They have won three consecutive promotions to return to the Scottish Premiership, and have also won several domestic cups. However, they have yet to win a league title since their liquidation.
Comparing the achievements of the old and new Rangers is difficult, as they are essentially two different clubs. However, it is clear that the old Rangers were far more successful than the new Rangers have been so far. The old Rangers won 54 league titles, while the new Rangers have won none. The old Rangers won 33 Scottish Cups, while the new Rangers have won four. The old Rangers won 27 League Cups, while the new Rangers have won two.
It is also worth noting that the new Rangers have not yet had the opportunity to compete in European competition at the same level as the old Rangers. The old Rangers reached the final of the European Cup Winners’ Cup twice, while the new Rangers have only competed in the Europa League and have yet to progress beyond the group stage.
Despite this, many fans argue that the new Rangers are still the same club as the old Rangers. They point to the fact that the new Rangers play at the same stadium, wear the same colours, and have a similar badge. They also argue that the new Rangers have the same fanbase and history as the old Rangers.
Ultimately, whether or not the new Rangers are the same club as the old Rangers is a matter of opinion. However, it is clear that the new Rangers have a long way to go before they can match the achievements of the old Rangers. They will need to win a league title and compete in European competition at a high level to truly be considered one of the great Scottish football clubs.
Q&A
1. Are Glasgow Rangers the same club as the original Rangers FC?
Yes, Glasgow Rangers are considered to be the same club as the original Rangers FC.
2. Why is there controversy surrounding whether Glasgow Rangers are the same club?
The controversy stems from the club’s financial troubles in 2012, which led to the liquidation of the original Rangers FC. The current club, Glasgow Rangers, was formed as a new company and acquired the assets of the old club.
3. What is the position of the Scottish Football Association (SFA) on the matter?
The SFA recognizes Glasgow Rangers as the same club as the original Rangers FC.
4. What is the position of rival club Celtic FC on the matter?
Celtic FC and their fans do not recognize Glasgow Rangers as the same club as the original Rangers FC.
5. How do Glasgow Rangers fans feel about the controversy?
Many Glasgow Rangers fans believe that their club is the same as the original Rangers FC and reject any suggestion to the contrary.
Conclusion
Yes, Glasgow Rangers are the same club despite going through financial difficulties and being liquidated in 2012. The club was reformed and continued to play under the same name and with the same history and traditions. This was confirmed by the Scottish Football Association and the Court of Session in 2018.